The Annuity Surge: Opportunity or Overexposure?
What if the annuity boom we're cheering is quietly setting the stage for future client regret?
From Q3 2023 to Q3 2024, U.S. annuity sales soared 29%. Fixed annuities led the charge with a jaw-dropping 54% increase. The headlines—from Annuity.org to Insurance Journal—are celebratory. But as financial professionals, we need to pause and ask: what’s behind this surge, and are we equipping clients to win long-term—or just chasing short-term trends?
The Numbers Behind the Noise
Let’s start with the good news: LIMRA reported total U.S. annuity sales at a record-breaking $432.4 billion in 2024, up 12% from the previous year. Fixed-rate deferred annuities (FRDAs), the annuity equivalent of a CD, drew in conservative investors with guaranteed yields. Meanwhile, Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs) and Registered Index-Linked Annuities (RILAs) gained traction for their market-upside-with-downside-protection appeal.
This isn’t a blip. It’s a paradigm shift driven by three intersecting forces:
Demographics – 10,000 Baby Boomers retire daily.
Volatility Anxiety – After years of market chaos, clients crave certainty.
Regulatory Tailwinds – SECURE 2.0 made annuities more accessible inside retirement plans.
But we can’t just celebrate the demand. We must dissect the delivery.
What the Numbers Don’t Say: Product Fit vs. Product Hype
Here’s the hard truth: Fixed annuities surged, but many of those sales were rate-chasing—not retirement-planning.
We’re seeing a wave of short-duration fixed contracts locking clients into 3- or 5-year commitments at peak interest rates. Advisors are presenting MYGAs like bond replacements, but without a long-term income strategy. What happens when rates drop and those dollars roll off? Will the advisor still be there to reinvest wisely? Or will that rollover land in a less competitive product?
This is the ethical moment of truth for our industry. Are we educating clients on annuity roles (income, longevity protection, legacy planning)—or simply selling yield?
FIA and RILA: Tools or Traps?
Fixed Indexed Annuities and RILAs offer structured upside with limited downside. But let’s not gloss over the fine print:
Are clients being told how caps, spreads, and participation rates affect real returns?
Are illustrations showing realistic, net-of-fee scenarios—or just cherry-picked historical highs?
Do advisors understand how these products perform over 10+ year holding periods versus the market?
We believe in these products when used correctly. But their increasing complexity demands a more sophisticated advisor—not just a sharper sales pitch.
Compliance and Competence Must Rise Together
Nearly every state has adopted the NAIC's "Best Interest" Model Regulation. That’s a step forward. But the best interest standard is only as good as the professional implementing it.
Firms must:
Mandate product training beyond basic licensing.
Enforce post-sale service standards to monitor product performance.
Prioritize suitability reviews tied to actual client goals—not product placement.
Annuities aren’t bad. But bad annuity advice is a liability—for clients and the industry alike.
Practical Strategies for Ethical Growth
Segment your annuity strategy: Use fixed annuities for principal protection, FIAs/RILAs for long-term growth buffers, and income annuities for longevity risk. Don’t treat them interchangeably.
Set a review calendar: Every annuity sale should come with a 12-month review plan—minimum. Track caps, renewal rates, and client circumstances.
Document intent: Advisors should clearly articulate (in writing) why a product was chosen and what role it plays. This protects both parties.
Lead with education: Explain liquidity restrictions, surrender charges, and tax treatment before the client signs—not after.
Final Word: The Surge is Real—But So Is the Responsibility
We’re entering an annuity renaissance. But as professionals, we must evolve from order-takers to fiduciary architects. The goal isn’t just more sales—it’s smarter sales that build sustainable income, reinforce trust, and stand up to regulatory scrutiny.
Let’s make this moment not just a sales spike, but a standards reset.
Join the conversation. How are you using annuities more ethically and effectively in your practice?
Want more critical insights like this? Subscribe to stay ahead of the curve—and on the right side of ethical innovation.
