Surge in Disability Claims Amid Post-Pandemic Landscape: A Wake-Up Call for Insurers
The disability insurance industry is facing a reckoning. Since 2020, disability claims have surged by 35%, with the number of Americans reporting disabilities climbing to 38.8 million by late 2023. This isn’t just a statistical anomaly—it’s a seismic shift that is reshaping the risk landscape for insurers, employers, and policyholders alike.
What’s Driving the Surge?
A combination of factors is fueling this unprecedented rise in disability claims:
Long COVID & Lingering Health Issues – The long-term effects of COVID-19, including chronic fatigue, respiratory complications, and neurological disorders, have left many unable to work.
Mental Health Crisis – Anxiety, depression, and PTSD have skyrocketed, leading to more claims for mental health-related disabilities.
Exacerbation of Pre-Existing Conditions – The pandemic delayed routine healthcare, worsening chronic conditions and increasing the need for disability benefits.
How This Impacts Insurers
The financial strain on disability insurers is undeniable. A 35% spike in claims means higher payouts, tighter reserves, and the looming prospect of increased premiums. Here’s what insurers are grappling with:
1. Pricing Pressures & Rising Premiums
Expect disability insurance premiums to climb. With more claims and greater financial exposure, insurers will have no choice but to recalibrate pricing models to protect solvency.
2. Tougher Underwriting Standards
Underwriters will tighten their scrutiny of applicants, particularly for occupations at higher risk of long COVID or mental health disorders. Expect more medical exams, longer waiting periods, and stricter policy exclusions.
3. Expanded Product Offerings
To address these challenges, insurers will likely innovate. Hybrid policies combining disability coverage with long-term care benefits or wellness programs could gain traction, offering both prevention and protection. A prime example of this trend is John Hancock’s newly introduced LifeCare with Vitality, which integrates wellness into long-term care coverage, signaling a broader industry shift toward proactive health management.
Broader Implications: Beyond Insurance
The ripple effects extend far beyond the insurance industry:
Employer-Sponsored Plans Under Strain – With more workers filing claims, employers may face rising costs for group disability plans.
Social Security Disability at Risk – The federal system is already under pressure, and a continued rise in claims could accelerate funding shortfalls.
Workforce Participation Challenges – A growing disabled workforce could reshape hiring practices, workplace accommodations, and remote work policies.
Final Thoughts: A New Era for Disability Insurance
The surge in disability claims isn’t a short-term blip—it’s a long-term reality that insurers, employers, and policymakers must address. Expect continued shifts in underwriting, pricing, and product development as the industry adapts to this new landscape. For consumers, now is the time to review coverage, understand policy limitations, and prepare for potential premium hikes.
One thing is clear: disability insurance is no longer a niche concern. Insurers must adapt with smarter underwriting and innovative products, while policyholders should proactively review their coverage to ensure they’re prepared for an evolving risk landscape. It’s a front-and-center issue that will shape financial planning, healthcare policy, and the workforce for years to come.
Stay Ahead of the Curve Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest insights on insurance, annuities, and financial planning strategies!
